AELE LAW LIBRARY OF CASE SUMMARIES:
Civil Liability of Law Enforcement Agencies
& Personnel
Search and Seizure: Computer Related
Target of government
investigation was entitled to a preliminary injunction barring federal
government agents from compelling his Internet service provider (ISP) to
disclose the contents of his email without a warrant, notice, or a hearing.
Such a disclosure would violate his rights under the Fourth Amendment,
and a federal statute. A person retains a reasonable expectation of privacy
as to the content of e-mail, even though they are stored with, sent, or
received through a commercial ISP. The fact that such emails might be screened
to exclude spam, viruses, and child pornography did not remove that reasonable
expectation of privacy. The court did state that, if the defendant government
could demonstrate factually that the plaintiff had waived his expectation
of privacy in relation to the ISP, then disclosure of the emails through
a mere notice to the ISP would be allowable. Warshak v. US, No. 06-4092,
2007 U.S. 14297 (6th Cir.).
301:13 Police officers entitled to qualified
immunity for seizing, pursuant to valid warrant, computer used to transmit
obscene materials, even if it also contained non-obscene electronic mail
belonging to users of on-line computer bulletin board; good faith reliance
on search warrant gave officers complete statutory defense to claim under
federal statute barring unauthorized interception of electronic communications.
Davis v. Gracey, 111 F.3d 1472 (10th Cir. 1997).